Blog Cabin
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

I don't know

5/18/2020

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

So much of my thinking generally is in support of I don't know. Yes, to be sure, I like to critique and note where ideas and practices fail. And no, I do not usually fill that newly created gap with new answers. Perhaps you could argue "what good are you doing then Philip? Others are out here trying, what are you adding by tearing down?"

I don't know, and that is ok. Individual solutions don't have to be up to me nor, and this make come as a relief, up to you. It may feel like there is pressure to have an answer, but that is in your head. We are a world of nearly eight billion, if you or I do not have the solution, there are others who can take a stab at it.

This is why I believe strongly in ideas like cultural responsiveness and diversity of thought. It's not just that it is 'fair' to let other people lead fulfilling lives, but that we reap benefits when they do. Bringing in additional perspectives from other cultures has been shown time and again to lead to the answers that I or you personally do not have. It is a way to curb group think, and freshen up old ideas.

I do not know the answer to the many serious questions that exist now and those that are opened up by new critique. But someone does, or even better, a group of someones can figure them out. Rather than answer the questions, I would prefer to facilitate environments where diversity of thought can emerge.

Questionable decision making in the past has come back to haunt us in many serious ways. Those decisions were often made by a narrow body of people. Opening up to new answers and new ways of doing things is I don't know, maybe the answer?
Picture
Pilipili Mulongoy, Untitled, 1955.
0 Comments

Citizen Kane and the Life Not Lived

11/4/2018

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

“I am an American.” For having been spoken by the world’s sixth richest man at a time when he was focused on his political image, that may be the truest line in Citizen Kane. For Charles Foster Kane is a caricature of the American male; caricature being the truth exaggerated.

The movie begins with members of the media seeking to find the meaning behind “Rosebud,” Kane’s final word. 77-year old spoiler alert: Rosebud was the name of Kane’s childhood sled. We see boy Charlie and his sled in one of the first scenes. It is the only time we see him gleefully happy, and possibly the final time in his life that he was entirely satisfied with himself. Nearby, a group of adults had gathered to stand around and talk, but Charlie knows that is just what adults do. Why don’t adults sled down hills? Why don’t adults play?

Adults have forgotten how to play, Charlie. They have suffered through the trauma of having their youth torn away. This shredding can come from the cruel words of stigma from another child. Or it can be the result of a group of adults who, after standing around talking, grab your sled and announce “we have made a Decision.” Adulthood, with its stresses and its hard facts pushes out the old memories. The childhood trauma of being torn and shred is among the first cargo jettisoned.

In The Decemberists song Infanta (2005) a parade of dignitaries and princes is described. There is folderol, there is chaparral, there is coronal and there is every other bit of the Fancy adults garment themselves with. At the end of the parade is the main course to be served up to society, the young infanta. The babe is weary of all these adult trappings; “the babe all in slumber dreams/of a place filled with quiet streams/and the lake where her cradle was pulled from the water.”

Charlie Kane’s lake was a mound of snow in Colorado. Like the infanta, dumb and cruel luck deposited a deposit of gold on his head. Gold, a metal worthless to a child, a squirrel, a tulip or a sled. Gold, the most treasured object of the groups of adults who stand about talking of Decisions. As he slid atop Rosebud to the bottom of that mound, Charles Foster Kane crashed into the expectations of adulthood. He was gone too soon.

-

It is gravity that provides us the thrill of riding on a sled. It is gravity that holds our feet to this earth. And it is patriarchal, capitalist, “traditional” expectation that holds our feet to the flame. The next Kane we see is a healthy, robust man in his 20s. Outwardly, the ideal vision of brash and bold youth. He sweeps into his newspaper office believing himself to be the spear-tip of the mandate of a new age. He writes a declaration of principles in John Hancock font size. And indeed that declaration was meant for all the kings to see. Yet his proactive appearance hides a reactive nature. When the bankerman who raised him after Kane was plucked from the snow asks “what would you have liked to have been?,” speaking from the anger that must have been born on that train ride from Colorado to New York City, Kane replies “everything you hate.”

Picture
Kane finds a new toy
As a young man moves into middle adulthood in the United States, his so-called prime, he tends to go down one of two paths. If his fortunes are bad, then the vigorous youthful anger crystallizes into nigh unbreakable bitterness. If fortune has smiled her crooked teeth his way, he soon buys into the cult-cum-culture of professional ambition. Charles Kane, Man of the Roaring Twenties, trades in his political dissidence for the arm of the president’s daughter.

Perhaps some man, somewhere, can carry both ambition and contentment. Indeed perhaps some man, somewhere from sea to shining sea, can be ambitious, see that ambition faceplant on the pavement, sit up criss-cross-applesauce and say “I am more than fine just where I am.” I have not met that man, I am not that man, and if you’ve followed this essay so far you know Citizen Kane is not that man.

With his public image secure, and an imminent election as governor days away, Charles decides to open the past’s crypt. In a warehouse on the other side of town are all the belongings from his childhood cabin, shipped in in wooden crates like priceless statues. Had he made it to that warehouse that day, surely he would have encountered Rosebud. Perhaps there, running his hands over rusted iron rails and chipping red paint he would have had an epiphany. He may have remembered the boy he once was, the one denied a chance to transition to adulthood. Possibly Kane may have vowed to use his forthcoming power to ensure that children everywhere were allowed to pursue their own dreams, and heed not the dictates of politicians, ad men, and financial advisers. Instead he meets his second wife.

I mean no misogyny by that last statement. Susan Alexander Kane is innocent of all crimes. Innocence, to Kane’s self-absorbed line of thought, is Susan’s primary quality. On that chance meeting in the street he is attracted to her firstly because she has never heard of him. He is relieved of the pressure to be The Man Who Acts; the pressure to be the one all faces turn to. Nostalgic for his never lived life, Susan’s youth becomes the drafting table on which he designs the life he would have lived. With Susan’s throwaway comment that she wanted to be an opera singer, but that her mother said getting a job might be better, Kane is filled with misplaced indignation. In body he is in her apartment, listening to her play the piano and sing, but in mind he has flown to Colorado.

Beyond those first few seconds on the street, Charles is never fully present with Susan. In 'liberating' her from the demands of dream-crushing adulthood, Kane imitates the mother, the father, and the banker that earlier determined his life. He builds a grand opera house for her to sing in, and the world’s stateliest birdcage to contain her. He is as deaf to her desires as he is tone deaf to her voice. For it was not motherly abandonment that ripped Susan from her dream, it was prudent motherly advice. Susan was as good at singing as boy Charlie was at sledding.

Kane never had that warehouse epiphany. His efforts to guide and control Susan’s musical career are a bastardization of the dreams of our childhood. One need only to watch a child alone at play to see this. A child’s life is marked by exploration and curiosity. Kids will try out and abandon this project or that. They will quite literally throw everything against the wall to see what sticks. But a child’s underdeveloped muscles are no match for the force of adulthood. We are all ripped from our playgrounds at one point or another. Rebecca Solnit tells of one family’s excursion to the Grand Canyon. At every scenic vista the family piles out. The adults look across at vast breadth, in awe of how the Colorado River has conquered the terrain. The children, by contrast, look at the “bones, pine cones, sparkly sandstone” at their feet. They are content on the ground, and will remain so until our voices telling them to look up and look out become loud enough.

Mastery and Control. The largest natural features, the tallest buildings, and the biggest personalities. This is what appears on our postage stamps. In Dubai, where little human culture existed prior to this century, Mastery and Control is that hollow grandiosity that the billionaires have imported. Our inner child may want to play, but our outer adult will accept only victory. Success, adoration, and the conquering of goals allows us to momentarily scream “I am something!” back at a universe that consistently reminds us in monotone that we are nothing.

After so many years of being his project, Susan Alexander walks out on Kane. There is a moment, as she is packing her luggage, when it appears that Kane has finally seen that she is an independent human being. Having her voice recognized being all Susan really wanted, she hesitates. Epiphany was close again, but it did not come that second for Kane. His “you can’t do this to me” is enough to solidify her decision. They were the exact words he would have said to his mother and father all those years back, had he known what was to become of his life. Seeing the back of her, he destroys her bedroom in adultish rage. Manly anger brings down the shelves, smashes the hand-crafted Persian vases, upends the finest oak side-tables. But upon finding a simple snow globe, Kane is slugged in the gut. It is in that moment, with the distraction of Susan Alexander now past, that Kane metaphorically finds his way to the warehouse. Too old now to do a thing about it, Charlie Kane approaches the borderlands between the lives we construct and the truth we miss.

As bell hooks writes: “The patriarchal manhood that was supposed to satisfy does not. And by the time this awareness emerges, most patriarchal men are isolated and alienated; they cannot go back and reclaim a past happiness or joy, nor can they go forward. To go forward they would need to repudiate the patriarchal thinking that their identity is based on.”

Charles Foster Kane does not live to repudiate anything. The idea that we men are merely reacting to forces around us is unfathomable to a culture that so prizes action. In the end Kane has only regret. He does not order his papers to publish from the Deathbed of the Editor a letter to the boys and men, and girls, women, and citizens of the world informing them that we have been doing it all wrong. He has run out of time to flesh out the thought that begins with “Rosebud.” And the media men that opened the movie, the men so much responsible for the stories we tell ourselves and one another, shrug their shoulders and declare “I guess we’ll never know.”



Referenced herein:

hooks, b. (2004). The Will to Change: Men, Masculinity, and Love. New York: Washington Square Press
Solnit, R. (2005). A Field Guide to Getting Lost. New York: Viking
0 Comments

The Kiss That Corroded to Her Heart: Mikhail Vrubel's Seated Demon

12/30/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
Демон сидящий - Seated Demon, by Mikhail Vrubel (1890)
by Kate Caraway and Philip Monte Verde

Kate:

For a demon, he is beautiful. Framed by unnaturally large flowers at a golden dawn or dusk, he looks wistful. Perhaps mournful. Does he have a flower in his hair? In spite of his clearly delineated muscles, his sitting position is not a powerful one. He looks as if he has been bested by something; is he regrouping, resting? Plotting? Or does he have nothing left to do?

The green tint of his skin, his thick neck, and his long, steep jawbone seem to be suggestions of otherworldliness. But the emotion on his face is human. The beauty of his form is a human beauty. Nothing about him, neither himself nor his environment, hints at evil. He is not a jarring presence in the landscape; the color of his skin and the color of the sky are combined in the big flowers. He's a part of the world we see him in. It is a colorful, vibrant, living world. A warm wind blows his hair back, perhaps shifting the flowers beside him. But he is still.

He's the most precisely-painted thing in a collage-like setting, as if he's a real person sitting in front of a mosaic. The light on his body is painted smoothly, showing the specifics right down to the joints of his fingers. Different from the flowers that look assembled from scraps of paper, and different from the pixellated blur of the sky. Care has been taken with this demon, and he is weighted with cares himself. He seems elevated, sitting on a mountaintop, and yet there is a heaviness to him, an indelicacy to the scene, that is anything but carefree.

-

Philip:

It was only after encountering Seated Demon and feeling inspired to write about its artist, the Russian Mikhail Vrubel, that I made a personal connection. This whole time I have been writing about similar themes: abyss, lifeless voids, monsters we can’t quite understand. The pattern was not deliberate, rather just me writing what was on my mind. The analysis of that I will save for my therapist. The sudden tracking of this pattern, however, helped me empathize with Vrubel. 

For a decade this demon seemed to be all the artist could think about. He sketched the demon, he sculpted it, and he painted it. In his masterpiece, at the apex of his obsession, he shows the demon sitting in the sunset contemplating ultimate loss.

There is something so attractive about Russian culture. The country itself is one of Western familiarity and Siberian forest mystery. European culture laps up on St. Petersburg’s boggy edges in the west of the country. Its influence pushes in from the shores, as it does now on every continent of this earth. But as it advances it meets a different force coming from the east. It is a certain mentality that emerges from the dark woods, where dense pine canopies blot out the sun. No matter how much an outsider studies Russian history, this mentality can’t be fully comprehended; can’t be made tangible. At least I have had no luck in the pursuit.

Spend an hour reading a Tolstoy novel and you will encounter a character saying “ah, but what is to be done?” In the West, in the United States, this would be a call to action. “Ok, what’s our plan?” In Russia it is a rhetorical question. It is a phrase of acceptance. It says “yes, that is how it is, to be sure, but we can’t change that, so let’s move on.”
The demon that so obsessed Mikhail Vrubel’s mind is an illustration of the 1842 poem Demon by Mikhail Lermontov. Lermontov’s demon is an immortal being who wanders the Caucasus Mountains. He is a brutal tyrant, for immortality brings with it strength, but it also brings a curse to be alone. Heretofore unknown emotion stirs in him when he sees the beautiful Princess Tamara dancing at her wedding. Force being the only tool in the demon’s belt, he destroys the husband. Tamara (apparently forgiving him for that) falls for the demon, and sees in him not the Devil, but a tortured soul. She holds a belief that there is a human being beneath his rough exterior that just needs to be brought out. She’s right, and for a second she sees that human man. But for only a second. For this is Russia, land of few happy endings. The demon’s kiss is fire and it kills her.​
For straight with venom of damnation
That kiss corroded to her heart, 
And all the midnight echoes start
With a wild shriek of consternation--
A shriek that told a tale heartbreaking
Where love and agony blended,
From youth a passionate leave taking,
And that young life in terror ended.

​
And what is to be done, dear demon? In an eerie stained glass-like tableau Vrubel shows the immortal man sitting with the terrible disappointment; sitting with the full weight of his curse on his shoulder. I’m sorry demon, the tragedy of it is too much. We must turn away from you now.
0 Comments

Laura Marling's "The Beast" Imagined

12/3/2017

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

​The man Laura is singing to doesn’t quite get it, and how could he? We live our lives independently, cut off irrevocably from one another since the day they snipped the umbilical cord. The most empathetic of us still don’t know one percent of what is going on in our closest loved one’s head. This is the defining struggle of human relations.

("The Beast" by Laura Marling - Spotify link, YouTube link)

What Laura has been exposed to, as we arrive on the scene, is something he does not yet understand. Something foreign to him. Flashes of it in the mirror that he thinks are just tricks of the eye. Because he has not lived through what she has, he can not comprehend the change that has come over her. His context is not her inner reality, it is his daily, normal life. The changes confound him. What comes next he is wholly unprepared for.

To be fair, she tried to prevent this. For hours in anticipation of this moment, she has been scouring her insides for something different. She has rifled through her DNA for a certain power, for the strength of her ancestors. She tried to call on the might of the goddess who predates measured time. She sunk a line for her, in hope, but that baited hook plunged so deep didn’t pull up what she was looking for. It pulled up what she got instead.

She got the Beast. She is no longer the angler in control of the situation. Laura is the one bound by the nylon string, and it is the monster that pulls her in.
Picture
"The Slave Ship" by JMW Turner
Sylvia Plath saw this monster once. In Full Fathom Five she took her turn at describing him. A massive figure who defies godhood. No man who ever saw below that beast’s shoulders kept his head. They all breathed water. Sylvia did not survive the Beast. It would take her, far too soon. And here now is Laura, being pulled in by that rope, possibly to that same end.

Her blood boils in a rising crescendo. She lies with the Beast, it gets inside her. Her eyes glow red, the change comes over her. She sees visions of destruction: asteroids crashing, fires raging, bombs exploding, the fall of man. What that must do to a person, to fill up with all that is evil. Her lover - the mortal one, not the one she conjured up - looks at Laura puzzled. There is little sympathy in her hot eyes. The waning humanity in her urges him to be alert to the danger. To look in the mirror for more than a second, to comprehend and be thankful he is alive at all. This bed is not yours tonight, sir. Turn away, avert your eyes, run away until the Beast is done with your old lady.


​At 3 a.m. Laura comes to. She is exhausted, but will not be falling asleep so soon. Whatever has come over her has gone. She can no longer recall what she went through, who or what the Beast was. But she feels changed. She feels vulnerable, and she searches for her mortal lover. The familiarity of her need for him, brings him back to her. A chance after all that furor to be the man again. A chance to make her feel safe once again.
0 Comments

Connection

11/28/2017

2 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

Picture yourself in a one seat submarine, with a lone beam shining out on the deepest ocean floor. It is 3.8 billion years ago and you, dear time traveller, are staring at a hydrothermal vent gushing out piping hot water. Miles of skull-crushing water above you an Earth you wouldn’t recognize is being peppered with meteorites and bursting with volcanoes. Neither above or below is a place to find love or hope or connection.


Absolute silence; the silence of the unliving.

Reach your right hand over and press the light green button on your submarine control panel. The one that places the magnifying lens atop your viewing window. Pivot your camera just to the upper left of the vent opening. Consistent lines of hydrogen sulfide wave blurrily past the screen. They’re dotted here and there by copper and zinc atoms.

Patiently hold your gaze on that spot and await your reward. There it is, suddenly in your vision: Life. After millennia of streaming out without result, the right combination of a dozen different chemicals connected in the right order and a cell was created. She is Eve, and she is the great, great, great times infinity grandmother of you and I. She is the matriarch of the trees in the forest and the fish in the sea. She is the mother of the disease and of the cure. Hello mama.

For a little while she just sits there, being present. In front of you is all of life. Everyone who has ever been and who will ever be were united and contained in a squishy little bit invisible to the naked eye. Everyone in Canada, in Cancun, in Calcutta, in your city and in mine. Every bone in every graveyard packed in like sardines. Packed in with every sardine. We were once one.

And then, tragically, Eve split in two. She begat Adam who begat Abel who begat Yasmin who begat Sophia who begat Joe, Todd, Tyler, Ahmed, and Nicole. For there was another rider in that cell alongside all of us. Hidden deep within that first string of DNA was an urge to keep going. That urge, the essence of life, decided early on that it had worked too hard to get here to exit the universe’s stage with the expiration of Eve’s flimsy body.

Earthly life has since gone out in an incalculable number of directions. It has risen out of the deep dark sea and crawled onto land, where it grips into the soil or pushes off into the air. Soon it will begin conquering other planets. It will go and it will go and it may never stop.

But an interesting thing happened not too long after the birth, life, and death of Eve. The cells had gone on splitting for many generations. They ventured further and further from the birth vent and banged against one another without thinking anything of it. Until one day a particular cell collided with another and instead of bouncing or bursting, they connected. This connection, two bodies becoming one, was as vital to our development as that moment when one body became two.

And it goes to illustrate a fundamental conflict in our hearts, our souls, our personal essences. As you sit there in your submarine, gazing at Eve, you surely can feel it. You have a deep, deep affinity for her, as you may for your own mother, your dog, your daughter, or the oak tree in your yard. You, we, desire connection. We go crazy without it. We will connect with a sexual partner in an urge to replicate that moment when we were united in Eve. But in doing so we make the same tragic mistake that pulled us so far away from original unity: we create a new life.

​
Picture
"Purple Grackle" by John James Audubon
2 Comments

The Abyss

11/1/2017

0 Comments

 
Published originally in six parts on the Tumblr

“And if thou gaze long into an abyss,
the abyss will also gaze into thee.”

Sometimes you’ll get lost in each other’s eyes. There you might stay for a week to ten days, like the common cold, or a honeymoon.

The abyss isn’t a movie, it isn’t a brand, nor a tar-pit-tourist-attraction. It is like a cave, or a hole in the ground, but not entirely. It is not by safety rope that you descend into the abyss, but in the head over heels tumble that follows a hard shove. Spinning and twisting is how you enter the darkness.

-

We all get shoved. Life, in all its survival of the fittest, can be seen as one constant shoving match. The minutiae or gargantua of anxieties, the sudden trauma, or the fearful consideration of the future all can send us spinning. Most will struggle to escape, with temporary success. What the abyss holds for them is merely put off until another day. And the abyss, now having a taste for you, will only grow hungrier and more aggressive week to month. Others believe they can control their descent, deny they are being tossed about. Folly. The abyss is pitch black, it doesn’t matter which way your toes are pointing.

​-
​
Picture
​I do not know where the abyss resides. I have seen it in my bedroom and tried to hide from it under my pillow. I have seen it while driving in my car, I have seen it while soaking in the shower. I have seen it, on occasion in the faces of others. Either side of a forced smile, it hides with the mites in wrinkles and dimples.

We humans, so spatial, so organized, have mapped out the brain. The cerebellum, the hypothalamus, and all the lobes have been assigned functions. Computers are made in our image, or perhaps our idea of ourselves are made in theirs. Every inch of grey defined; no room in the skull for the incomprehensible.

-

But I have seen the incomprehensible, perhaps you have too. The abyss exists, and sometimes it comes to you. Tentacled arms reach out menacingly, demandingly. What is it it so greedily demands? Perhaps it is material goods. You fling televisions and all-inclusive vacations at it. Cheap sugar highs and empty calories, no, it demands more. You lose time and space for others, the tentacles have grabbed control of the wheel. The abyss has transformed from black nothing into a red demon. Anything can happen now: sadness, frustration, your anger turns outward. Violence works too, red blood leaving no stain on the demon’s arms.

-

How do we deal with this abyss, before it rises out and consumes us all? If the hole in the ground can’t be avoided and you fall in, or if you walk in, or even if you dive in, what then? Well, I say explore it. It is dark in there, but there is no such thing as empty. Ignore the reputation of the abyss, make room for a second impression. For it is no alien, nor any demon inside you, those tentacles are your own. I know this is difficult. You have jobs to work, children to rear, bridal and baby showers to attend. There is little time in the Age of Busyness for self-exploration and introspection. And even less so when we believe there is no meaning. But is this so?

-
​
There is a why behind everything, I think. This seemingly senseless universe, full of scattered violence, and randomly distributed luck, it must have a why. All the atoms, molecules, protons and electrons that have gathered around you and among you must have a why. The abyss can’t be read on a CT scan, so studies of it are not peer-reviewed, they are personal. Hiding in that blackness, somewhere in your mind, are the reasons for everything you do. Etched in its walls is the story of your life. The effects of every interaction you’ve had with people and nature are grooves your fingers can touch, if you just reach out.

The abyss is not a dark hole looking to consume you. It is not a bottomless pit, it is an endless gift. And to think, it has been there all along.
0 Comments

Advice Column #1: On Domestic Violence

1/12/2017

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

Today's question:

Someone I'm Facebook friends with always posts about how her husband wont let her have certain friends, he won't let her get a drivers license, or let people watch their kids that HE doesn't approve of. How do I tell her this is abuse?

Intimate partner violence is far more complex and far more common than we think. There are professionals who would be far better at addressing this topic than I would. Willow for example here in Rochester, and the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence nationally. Disclaimer stated, I've studied the subject a bit and have some thoughts. 

First, it is important to address your own expectations. You aren't going to "save" this person, especially as they may not want to be saved. Getting into a relationship is easy. Getting into a bad relationship is ABSURDLY easy. And once you're in, you're invested. I've always understood this best through an economics term (wait, don't close this tab yet!) called the sunk cost fallacy. In this scenario someone who has already invested heavily in a business will continue to do so long after the business starts to lose money. The rational thing in these situations would be to cut the losses and move on. But we're humans and not emotionless robots, so we continue to invest in the hope that things will turn around. We chase good money after bad, rather than admit that we wasted our money. In relationships we are afraid to admit that we wasted our time, our energy, and our emotional reserves. The fear of admitting defeat and starting over are often greater than the pain we are going through. This is especially true the less overt the abuse is.

Next, let's focus on what your friend is doing. We often use Facebook as a place to vent and receive reassuring words from friends, acquaintances, colleagues, and sometimes that creepy guy who just wanted to look at your pictures. It may not be the best use of the platform, but it's a human one. Your friend may be stuck in a life that she can't get out of, and venting just may be how she handles it. It's natural to think less of your problems once you've got them off your chest. Because, well, objects weigh less on you when they aren't sitting on your chest. Temporarily free of that burden, your friend may react harshly to you criticizing her husband. Her Facebook posts may be the entirety of the bad he does, and with that subtracted she may see only the good left in him and defend him.

I know you are eager to jump on in and tell her that she is being abused. That is natural to anyone with a good heart. You may also want to suggest that she leave him, another natural impulse. But with such a sensitive topic we have to think how our words are being perceived, and how to make the best use of them. Instead of doling out one-size-fits-all advice we need to understand your friend's circumstances. This means finding out more information than comes from her Facebook posts. This means being a friend. 
Picture
Some antelope to break things up
​
​If there is a greater social need than to be heard and be understood I cannot name it. A genuine "how are you?" given not out of supermarket checkout line formality but with honest-to-goodness curiosity is like presenting a gift. It is also an excellent place to start with your friend, and just about the best use of Facebook Messenger. From there, using active listening skills and asking follow up questions you can build trust and rapport with your friend.


Something else you could say:
 
"I see from your posts you've been having a rough time." Simple really, note that it isn't even a question. I didn't add "are you ok?", which invites a conversation-stopping yes or no answer. Rather it is an invitation for your friend to expand on what has been troubling them. Going down this path you will hopefully find out more and more about her situation. Judging by her use of Facebook posts, she may be more than eager to share.
 
As this process continues you may face the impulse to jump in with an opinion. It's important to restrain yourself a bit. I suggest thinking about how much you enjoy when people who don't know you well tell you you are doing everything wrong and should change your lifestyle radically. Yeah, don't like that much, do you? Instead people need to come to conclusions on their own. In my personal experience this is how I've gotten the most out of therapists. I yap and yap about what is bugging me, they wait for a lull and ask a poignant question, I consider how what they've asked fits in with my line of thinking, and yap some more until I reach some breakthrough. Then I go home thinking that I solved my problem on my own and that therapy is a waste of money.

Her having a breakthrough and taking steps to regain control of her life is not going to happen immediately. Even with your best efforts it may not happen at all. But to me, a life not spent being there for others is a life wasted. So talk to your friend. Not as someone playing a Hollywood superhero, that is fiction. Nor as someone who knows what's best for everyone, that is annoying. But as a human on equal terms. You may even gain an offline friend out of it.
0 Comments

Violence in the Mirror

7/19/2016

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

"It is death that is spinning the globe."

Death is our common companion. The well-meaning protectors are misguided in their reasoning for removing cinematic death and violence from theater and television. They wrongly seek to preserve innocent minds as they would fine china, never letting them out into the world to acquire a few scratches. But although the rationale of the protectors is off, their ends should probably be met. For the scripted and acted deaths are miles from reality.

While I'm sure I had seen a hundred 'deaths' on television before then, those of knights, cowboys, and space-invaders, it was the deaths of my grandmothers that first exposed mortality to me. The first grandmother I saw made up artificially and surrounded by flowers in her casket. The second grandmother I saw frozen, twisted and real in her hospital bed. These are two images I will never be able to get out of my head, nor should I even try.

These are not the images we see from our living room sofas or reserved-in-advance recliner-style AMC movie theater seats. Here final words of encouragement for the living are uttered by an actor holding the wound in their chest before their head droops as if for a nap. Here the blood of the anonymous conquered is splattered upwards, and the camera pan follows to show the gnarled, dark face of the antagonist or the handsome, white-toothed face of the protagonist. The slumped actor is a minor plot point, and the death of the extra is an insignificant blink; a quickly snuffed candle. While the film crew, whether HBO or CNN, packs up to follow the fighting down the road, human beings lay moaning or silenced in open fields and shell-pocked streets. Whether they are portrayed in our fiction or our non-fiction as the good dead guys or the bad dead guys matters nil to the weeping families, the families that must mourn them if they died, or tend to their emotional and physical damage if they lived.
Picture
"Nocturne" by Eyvind Earle
One would think this would be perfect material for big and small screens alike. Our most common form of storytelling is that of the redemptive hero. He, still rarely she, who has had defeat laid on him, brick by brick, but manages to miraculously find the strength to burst through the masonry to triumph, until the next episode. What a way to build sympathy for the hero it would be then to show the common soldier in the post-op ward reaching to scratch a phantom itch in the pocket of air his arm had once filled. Or show the aged grandmother, hunched over a wood table, a long curl of ash running from the cigarette she lit and forgot in her worry of what to do with the orphaned grandchildren obliviously playing tag in the kitchen. Show the sleepless nights that follow the trauma of wartime rape. Show the pitiful efforts of the surviving villagers to remove rubble to reopen the bakery.

What sympathy these scenes would build if, indeed, that were the goal. The sad truth of it all is an elephant that has been stomping about the room unacknowledged for centuries. Building sympathy for the redemptive hero is not and has never been the goal. Tug on the high-cheek boned face of the knight whose armor shines through mud and blood and you will find his tan-but-not-too-tan skin peels off under your fingers. Gasp when you look up and see the sweaty, disheveled beard, hideous scars and wild, black eyes staring at you. For your hero and your villain are the same man. They are both yours, and they are you.

For in the two hours that The Joker holds an entire city at his mercy, we ride shotgun and feel that power vicariously. While Popeye fumbles for a can of spinach, we project on Bluto the Rapist "our own repressed anger, violence, rebelliousness or lust" and revel in the evil of it all. For fifty eight minutes in a Game of Thrones episode we indulge in the slaughter of the extras, before Jon Snow sends the baddies retreating until next week. He suppresses the evil we created in the first fifty eight, and in the final two minutes we have room to repress again our inner tendencies.

He who went outside the power structure in greed and lust (the criminal), is pushed back by he that went outside the power structure for more noble aims (the vigilante). Credits roll before we have a second to ponder how we got there. The lights come back up before we can consider how the villain was created, why we tune in every week for the slaughter, or an alternative way to fight evil beyond the violent methods that evil naturally prefers.

(quotes from Pilgrim at Tinker Creek and The Myth of Redemptive Violence)
0 Comments

Rebecca Solnit, Lost in Blue

6/23/2016

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

​"How do you go about finding that thing the nature of which is totally unknown to you?" This quote from the ancient philosopher Meno appears on page four of "A Field Guide to Getting Lost," but for author Rebecca Solnit it may as well have been the writing prompt at the top of each blank page on her word processor. Her book is full of self-described 'maps," attempts to demonstrate how she has navigated towards that undefined "thing." It shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone at this point that incessant busyness and multitasking aren't the surest way to find that thing. That thing sneaks in in overlooked places. It takes the talent of being lost, that is making the conscious choice to be fully present.

Across the yard where I write is a 6-foot wooden fence. A spider, probably of zero consequences size-wise, has zig-zagged webs across the picket tips. This would hardly be worth breaking my book-review-narrative up had the little bug-eating bugger not then had the nerve to somehow propel its tiny body five feet off the fence and three feet down to the back of a chair in the grass. I can only pray that it is now making the scaling trek back up a wood slat, only to leap and leap again to create a web the size of which no one of its species could ever dream.

The point of that, of course, is that you have to look up sometimes. In particular you have to look up at 9:45 a.m., in late June, when the sun is breaking perfectly through the maple leaves to show off the long, thin hair of that one strand of web. Just time it right.

Looking up is a start anyways. "Leave the door open for the unknown, the door into the dark," Solnit councils. Leaving it ajar, perhaps then it is important to acknowledge the threshold exists, and proceed to walk through that opening. To truly be lost, and to find, may require getting up from the patio table, the deep sunk couch, or the ergonomically designed, highly adjustable, $949.99 Aeron desk chair by Herman Miller.

"Lose the whole world...get lost in it, and find your soul." We've been retracing the same maps. When we say 'follow in someone else's footsteps,' it is meant quite literally. It's an easy habit to get into. As an infant, we would be devoured by wolves, or their modern equivalent raccoons, if we didn't have older humans to protect us and for us to emulate. Like migrating elephants, we follow these older humans trunk to tail through the first quarter, or third, or half(!) of our lives. A midlife crisis, classically defined, can really occur at any age. It's the moment you raise your now jumbo-sized head up and see the savanna alongside the trail. To see your body has grown stronger (or weaker) and that you've made plenty of money (or not), but that your soul isn't carried on this caravan.
Picture
IG: @hipnihilist
So where is our soul then? Solnit seems to love a little organization to her being lost, because every other chapter is entitled "The Blue of Distance". Yesterday, I had the privilege to go with a friend to an art show on the 26th floor of what used to be called the Chase Tower, here in Rochester New York. I can't recall the new name of the building, but tell a local you mean the big white skyscraper and they'll get what you mean. The art was blasé, but the view was magnifique. In my time I've set foot in every visible square mile of the panorama afforded, but of course it's different up here. Being able to see the breadth of Lake Ontario and the Genesee Valley that feeds it and feeds off it with one turn of the head was a real treat. In both cases we saw Solnit's blue of distance. It takes little imagination to picture how the blue of lake water interchanges with the blue of sky above Canada, but the effect in the south is more thought-provoking. The blue at the horizon is a "melancholy blue."

According to Solnit, "light at the blue end of the spectrum does not travel the whole distance from the sun to us." I guess it just gives up? So here my buddy and I are looking southeast towards Avon and beyond. From here, if you tilt your head towards your toes and lift up, your eyes briefly pass the vertigo-inducing view of the sidewalk far far below, sweep past the orange ants of construction workers placing new flooring down on the roof of the 12-story building next door, fly up through the narrow space between two skyscrapers like a field goal kick, rise above the South Wedge, the University of Rochester, Mt. Hope Cemetery, the Erie Canal, Henrietta, and beyond across fields of trees as small as moss from your God's eye view. And then, like the lazy blue light that traveled all those millions of miles from the sun, the view just quits. The cosmic painter takes their melancholy blue and brushes it over the wavy horizon hills. 'Did you see you all the detail I put into the city streets?' (s)he roars, 'don't be so ungrateful!'

Don't be so ungrateful indeed. Setting aside the thing whose nature is unknown to us, even that which we think we wish to attain is elusive. This is constantly evident when we look at the hordes of the never-satisfied rich. Even they (and we, and I) must be at least dimly aware that their map is faulty, yet they continue to, as Rumi says, fumble in the money bag for coins. Those hills above Avon we've spoken of, I've been to them and they were not blue. They were green when we drove past them on Father's Day, in February they were white. If I climbed them today they'd be green, they'd be brown, they'd be silver, and perhaps just maybe speckles of yellow, orange, and red would be dancing along their tree limbs. But that particular blue would not be attained. It would remain of distance. If we made the modest hike up the hill's spine, and then the more perilous climb of its cell phone tower, we would find that "deeper, dreamier blue" to have retreated further to the hills of Geneseo as surely as the retreating glaciers that carved all in our line of sight.

We may never be meant to get there, so Solnit presents us with a radical idea: "We treat desire as a problem to be solved...(focusing on) how to acquire it, rather then on the nature and the sensation of desire, though often it is the distance between us and the object of desire that fills the space in between with the blue of longing. I wonder sometimes whether with a slight adjustment of perspective it could be cherished as a sensation on its own terms, since it is as inherent to the human condition as blue as to distance?" To appreciate desire for desire's sake. Part of me thinks I have a better shot at driving south twenty miles to find myself in the thick of a melancholy blue haze.
0 Comments

Reopening the Day

5/14/2016

0 Comments

 
by Philip Monte Verde

​Ribs of mine, often I wish you would just go on holiday. Buy three tickets, and take my shirt and skin with you. Let my heart live openly.

I want my afternoons and evenings to fill with the joy of Saturday mornings. I want to write, to drive, to sing, to flirt, to kiss, to cry, to yell and scream. These ribs feel more like a chain than a shield. Layers of clothing cake on like the exhaust on glass that obscures views.

Openly. Not stuck behind unasked questions or subdued feelings. Ebullient with compliments. Smile-giving, life-reinforcing acknowledgements of the humanity in others. I want to give that face-reddening praise the way a loving husband gives flowers.

Oh, to take people out of the rut. To gently tug up a chin as a 1950's leading man might, to make moment cementing eye contact, and to tell a man, woman, or child that they are beautiful. That they are charming. That they exist.

That they exist. Too often we forget that even we exist. We lose sight of the only truth: that we are part of this world.

Picture

​I sat in my car with the door open one sunny morning. Morosely, I pondered absolutely nothing, stared into the space between objects, and cracked open sunflower seeds. The shells I spat out on the driveway without thought. Time passed outside the head that I was stuck in. I got up and continued the motions of productivity. In the afternoon I returned to that driveway. Looking down, as I had been all day, I noticed little black ants had found the remnants of the sunflower seeds. Diligent strongmen had clamped seed meat in their mandibles. Fleet scouts left curling pheromone trails to guide their brothers to the next lode. I could almost picture the food being prepared for the colony by chubby ants in tiny chef hats.


Knowing I was helping to feed an over-sized family, I sat back down and cracked more sunflower seeds with my now smiling teeth. It was a timely reminder from the littlest among us that I was part of something larger.
0 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.